Twilight's Kiss poster

Twilight’s Kiss

CompletedMovie🇭🇰

SYNOPSIS

Every morning Pak (Tai Bo) puts on his driver's shirt and takes his taxi out into Hong Kong, because at seventy the alternative is the retirement his family keeps suggesting and he keeps declining. He has a wife, Ching (Patra Au), grown children, and a life assembled over decades out of provision and routine. Hoi (Ben Yuen) has already stopped working. He raised his son alone, lives in that son's devout household now, and takes his greatest pleasure in his granddaughter. The two men fall into conversation in a public park, and what starts there is something neither of them has ever had words for.

The film moves between two worlds that are not allowed to touch. In one, both men are fathers and providers, and a single wrong sentence would cost everything forty years went into building. In the other, made of parks, bathhouses and borrowed afternoons, they can be plain with each other. Ray Yeung films both without pity and without judgment, and the pressure on the pair is not a villain but arithmetic: what is still available to a man to choose once children, grandchildren and a marriage have already fixed the shape of his days. A second strand widens the question. Hoi sits in on meetings of an advocacy circle of older gay men campaigning for a retirement home where residents could live openly, which pulls a private story into a public argument about ageing, housing and who gets recognised. Faith, guilt and the wish for some form of continuity run under all of it.

Suk Suk, which means simply uncle in Cantonese, grew out of Oral Histories of Older Gay Men in Hong Kong by the sociologist Travis S. K. Kong. Yeung read the book, contacted its author, met surviving interviewees over dinners and home visits, and worked on the script from 2016 to 2019, blending several accounts rather than adapting one; the meeting between Pak and Hoi is his own invention. It was his third feature and his first shot in his home city and in Cantonese, financed largely by crowdfunding from within the LGBT community, and casting the two leads took roughly a year. The 92-minute film premiered at Busan in October 2019, took five nominations at the 56th Golden Horse Awards, played Panorama at the 2020 Berlinale, and won Best Actor for Tai Bo and Best Supporting Actress for Patra Au at the 39th Hong Kong Film Awards.

CONTENT DETAILS

Native Title
叔.叔
Original Title
Twilight's Kiss
Also Known As
叔.叔, Twilight's Kiss
Themes
Key Themes
RomanceDramaFamily
Country
Language
Cantonese
Networks
Duration
92 min
Aired Start
Aired End
Release Year
Content Rating
Category IIB

WATCH ON

GagaOOLala

MAIN CAST & CHARACTERS

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • A Hong Kong feature film, running 92 minutes, released on 2019-10-04.
  • Directed by Ray Yeung, written by Ray Yeung.
  • An original screenplay.
  • Produced by New Voice Film Productions.
  • Led by Tai Bo as Pak, Ben Yuen as Hoi.

EDITOR’S VERDICT

8.6/10

Reviewed by Renkaze, editor of BL & GL Flix

Almost every film about a first love is about people who have nothing yet. This one is about two men who have everything already: wives, grown children, grandchildren, forty years of provision, and no room whatsoever. That inversion is not a gimmick. It changes what the story can be about, because Pak and Hoi are not deciding what to become, they are calculating what is still available.

The arithmetic of a late life

Ray Yeung's best decision is to let the obstacle be a sum rather than a villain. Nobody in Suk Suk is cruel. The wife is not monstrous, the devout household is not a trap set for anyone, and the taxi keeps needing to be driven. What stands between the two men is the simple total of what other people have come to depend on, and Yeung films that without pity, a choice he has traced to one interviewee who said he had no regrets about a lifetime in the closet because he had a wife who made him soup and children who gave him an allowance, and called himself a success story. Variety's review identifies exactly what results, "smartly observed, naturalistic moments" in a "sympathetic and non-judgmental screenplay", and Tai Bo's Best Actor wins at the 39th Hong Kong Film Awards and from the Hong Kong Film Critics Society, which also named it Best Film, are not consolation prizes for a worthy subject.

Research that earns its place, and one that does not

The film grew from Travis S. K. Kong's oral histories of older gay men in Hong Kong, and Yeung went further than reading the book: he contacted Kong, met surviving interviewees, and spent three years blending accounts rather than adapting one. It shows in the texture — the bathhouses, the parks, a man clearing away memorabilia before an official visit. The advocacy strand, in which Hoi's circle campaigns for a retirement home where residents could live openly, comes from the same fieldwork and is the one part that feels transcribed rather than dramatised. It states the film's argument aloud in meetings, which a film this good at implication did not need. Variety also flags the musical passages as something "some might find maudlin", and that is the right place for the reservation to sit.

One compromise worth naming

A film whose entire claim is on the truth of old age cast a lead who was around fifty and put him in ageing makeup. Ben Yuen is very good, and the choice still slightly undercuts the argument the production is making about visibility, particularly beside Tai Bo, who is simply the age he is. It is a small thing against a film that went to Busan, took five Golden Horse nominations, played Panorama at the Berlinale and was financed largely by crowdfunding from within the community it depicts. Restraint is the method throughout, so viewers waiting for a confrontation will wait ninety-two minutes; what they get instead is the rarer thing, a love story in which nothing is available and both men know it.

Final Score: 8.6/10

What Twilight’s Kiss is about

The film follows two married men in their sixties and seventies who meet by chance in a public park and begin a relationship that neither can name openly. Its subject is the long private cost of a life arranged around family duty, and what remains possible once retirement, grown children and grandchildren have already fixed the shape of that life. It sets desire against obligation, tracking how the men move between a domestic world built on decades of provision and the parallel spaces where they can meet.

A second strand follows an advocacy circle of older gay men pressing for a retirement home that would house them openly, which places the private story inside a question about ageing, housing and public recognition. Faith, guilt and the wish for a form of continuity after death also run through the closing passages.

Suk Suk world premiered at Busan in 2019, went on to the Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival and five nominations at the 56th Golden Horse Awards, and then played Panorama at the 2020 Berlinale, where SBS reported it finished runner up for the Teddy Award, the festival's queer prize. Strand Releasing took North American rights and the film played Frameline and the San Francisco film festival on its way to release.

Ray Yeung chairs the Hong Kong Lesbian and Gay Film Festival, and his earlier features Cut Sleeve Boys and Front Cover were made in Western settings, so this was his first film shot in his home city and in Cantonese. M+ later programmed it in its Hong Kong: The Establishing Shot series in 2022 under the subchapter A Different View, with post screening talks by cinematographer Leung Ming-kai and by Yeung. The museum's programme note frames the film through the lost urban sites and hidden spaces of Hong Kong, including public toilets and gay bathhouses.

Best scenes in Twilight’s Kiss

  • Pak and Hoi first meet in a public park and fall into conversation.
  • The two men spend time together at a gay bathhouse.
  • Hoi's circle of older gay friends lobbies for a retirement home where residents could live openly as gay men.
  • One of the men clears out personal memorabilia, a scene Ray Yeung has said was drawn from an interviewee who hid his Hello Kitty collection before a welfare officer's visit.
  • Near the end Pak returns the cross that Hoi had given him, and the film closes with Pak sitting inside a church.

Interesting facts about Twilight’s Kiss

  • Character credits: Tai Bo as Pak (lead); Ben Yuen as Hoi (lead); Patra Au as Ching (support); Lo Chun Yip as Wan (support).
  • The original title is 叔.叔.
  • 2019, Golden Horse Awards (56th), Best Narrative Feature, Suk Suk, Nominated
  • 2019, Golden Horse Awards (56th), Best Original Screenplay, Ray Yeung, Nominated
  • 2019, Golden Horse Awards (56th), Best Leading Actor, Ben Yuen, Nominated
  • 2019, Golden Horse Awards (56th), Best Leading Actor, Tai Bo, Nominated
  • 2019, Golden Horse Awards (56th), Best Supporting Actress, Patra Au, Nominated
  • 2020, Berlin International Film Festival (70th), Best Feature Film, Ray Yeung, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Actor, Tai Bo, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Supporting Actress, Patra Au, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Film, Suk Suk, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Director, Ray Yeung, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Screenplay, Ray Yeung, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Supporting Actor, Lo Chun Yip, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best New Performer, Patra Au, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Editing, William Chang and Nose Chan, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Awards (39th), Best Costume and Make Up Design, Albert Poon, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards, Best Film, Suk Suk, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards, Best Actor, Tai Bo, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards, Best Director, Ray Yeung, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards, Best Screenplay, Ray Yeung, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards, Best Actor, Ben Yuen, Nominated
  • 2020, Hong Kong Film Directors' Guild Awards, Best Actor, Tai Bo, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Screenwriters' Guild Awards, Best Screenplay, Ray Yeung, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Screenwriters' Guild Awards, Best Role in a Screenplay, Tai Bo, Won
  • 2020, Hong Kong Screenwriters' Guild Awards, Best Role in a Screenplay, Patra Au, Nominated
  • 2020, Renaissance Awards, Best Drama, Suk Suk, Won
  • 2020, Wicked Queer Boston LGBT Film Festival, Jury Award for Best Narrative Feature, Twilight's Kiss, Won
  • 2020, Out on Film Atlanta LGBT Film Festival, Jury Award for Best International Film, Twilight's Kiss, Won
  • 2020, Out on Film Atlanta LGBT Film Festival, Jury Award for Best Actor, Tai Bo, Won
  • 2020, Out on Film Atlanta LGBT Film Festival, Audience Award for Best International Film, Twilight's Kiss, Won
  • 2022, GLAAD Media Awards, Outstanding Film Limited Release, Suk Suk, Nominated
  • 2022, Queerties Awards, Best Indie Movie, Twilight's Kiss, Nominated
  • Ray Yeung told Film Inquiry that the title Suk Suk simply means uncle in Cantonese.
  • China Times reported that Yeung approached more than a hundred actors, starting with established names and widening to television and radio performers, before the two leads were set.
  • China Times reported that a park used as a location was picked for convenience, and that the team only learned afterwards that it was a known 魚塘, local slang for a gay meeting spot.
  • China Times reported that Yeung discovered only during production that Ben Yuen had appeared in the 2018 Hong Kong film Tracey (翠絲).
  • Vogue Hong Kong's feature on the film credits art director William Chang Suk-ping (張叔平) as its editor.
  • M+ lists Leung Ming-kai as cinematographer and hosted his post screening talk in Cantonese and English on 19 June 2022.
  • Yeung told Junkee that shooting in Hong Kong let him drop race as a narrative concern for the first time, which he called liberating after films set in Western contexts.
  • The Berlinale entry lists four producers on the film: Michael J. Werner, Teresa Kwong, Sandy Yip and Chowee Leow.
  • World premiere at the Busan International Film Festival, October 2019.
  • Official Selection at the 2019 Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, with five nominations at the 56th Golden Horse Awards including Best Narrative Feature and Best Original Screenplay, and Best Leading Actor nominations for both Tai Bo and Ben Yuen.
  • Best Film at the Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards for 2019, with Best Actor going to Tai Bo.
  • Best Actor for Tai Bo and Best Supporting Actress for Patra Au Ga-man at the 39th Hong Kong Film Awards.
  • Selected for Panorama at the 70th Berlin International Film Festival in 2020; SBS reported it was runner up for the Teddy Award.
  • Official Selection at Frameline and at the San Francisco film festival, per Columbia University School of the Arts.
  • Programmed by M+ in Hong Kong: The Establishing Shot on 19 June 2022 and 7 September 2022, each with a post screening talk.
  • International availability: World sales handled by Films Boutique, per the Berlinale programme entry. Strand Releasing acquired North American rights and ran US virtual cinema screenings from 10 February 2021 across multiple venues, with the film then available on iTunes, Amazon Prime Video, Google Play and Vudu. Hong Kong theatrical release on 14 May 2020, Category IIB, 92 minutes, in Cantonese. Taiwan theatrical release on 27 February 2020 through distributor 采昌. The film is also listed on Apple TV under both the Twilight's Kiss and 叔.叔 titles.

How Twilight’s Kiss was made

Writer and director Ray Yeung developed the film after reading Oral Histories of Older Gay Men in Hong Kong by Travis S. K. Kong, a sociologist at the University of Hong Kong, which collects interviews with elderly gay men in the city. Yeung contacted Kong, met several of the interviewees over dinners and home visits, and drew details of their accounts into a script he worked on from 2016 to 2019. Tai Bo, Ben Yuen and Patra Au built their roles from that material, with Au stating that she modelled the wife Ching partly on her cousin's wife.

The film was produced by New Voice Film Productions, shot in Cantonese, edited by William Chang and Nose Chan, and runs 92 minutes. It premiered at the 24th Busan International Film Festival on 4 October 2019 and screened in the Panorama section of the 70th Berlin International Film Festival in 2020. Golden Scene released it in Hong Kong cinemas on 28 May 2020, and Strand Releasing handled the North American release in February 2021.

Direction is credited to Ray Yeung. The screenplay is credited to Ray Yeung. The film uses the Mandarin song 微風細雨 (Gentle Breeze and Drizzle), performed in the film's version by Qing Shan, written and composed by Lin Gongxin and originally recorded by Liu Lanxi. No official soundtrack album or official audio upload was located. Original music for the film is credited to Veronica Lee.

Hong Kong theatrical classification. Hong Kong films are classified under the Film Censorship Ordinance by the Office for Film, Newspaper and Article Administration; the category IIB listing for 叔.叔 appears on the Hong Kong cinema listings service WMOOV.

M+ records that Yeung spent four years developing Suk Suk, his third feature and his first Cantonese language film. He came to the material through Travis S. K. Kong's oral history research, contacted Kong at the University of Hong Kong, and then met and spent time with some of the surviving interviewees before writing. Yeung told Junkee that the film was ultimately financed through crowdfunding, largely from investors within the LGBT community, several of whom came to the table reads.

The film was produced by New Voice Film Productions, with Michael J. Werner, Teresa Kwong, Sandy Wai Shan Yip and Chowee Leow as producers, Yeung and Stan Guingon as executive producers and Leung Ming-kai as cinematographer, and runs 92 minutes. It world premiered at the Busan International Film Festival in October 2019, opened in Taiwan on 27 February 2020 through 采昌, and opened in Hong Kong on 14 May 2020 with a Category IIB rating. Yeung has said he rehearsed the intimate scenes as choreography first, comparing them to action or musical numbers, and then asked the actors to drop the technique and play them naturally.

Ray Yeung told Film Inquiry that he found Tai Bo through Philip Yung's 2009 film Glamorous Youth, liked his naturalistic playing and approached him directly, and that Tai Bo agreed after reading the script and showing it to his wife. China Times reported that Tai Bo took about two months to decide, that his wife read the script and gave her approval, and that she visited the set during shooting.

Yeung told Film Inquiry that he noticed Ben Yuen in a Hong Kong government produced television drama, admired his body language and understated playing, and telephoned him directly; Yuen, then around fifty, wore ageing makeup for the part, and China Times reported that his stage background had already included kissing scenes. Patra Au came to the film after Yeung cold called the Hong Kong Repertory Theatre, whose management recommended her, and he screen tested her before casting because she was primarily a stage actress. Yeung has said in interviews with New Bloom and Junkee that casting the two leads took roughly ten to twelve months and involved travelling repeatedly between Hong Kong and Taipei, where Tai Bo was living.

Suk Suk grew out of Oral Histories of Older Gay Men in Hong Kong by Travis S. K. Kong (江紹祺) of the University of Hong Kong's Department of Sociology, published in Chinese as 男男正傳; New Bloom describes the book as gathering roughly a dozen men in their sixties and seventies, and Chinese language coverage of the film gives twelve men aged 63 to 89. Yeung read the book, reached out to Kong, and then met and spent time with some of the men who were still living, saying he felt it urgent to record their experiences. He told Roar News that rather than adapting one account he recreated the story by taking parts from different men and blending them into a love story, which let him address the difficult material without making the film only about suffering.

He has repeatedly cited one interviewee who, asked whether he regretted a lifetime in the closet, said he did not, because he had a wife who made him soup and children who gave him an allowance, and called himself a success story; Yeung has said this shaped his decision to present the characters without pity or judgment. Yeung also told Junkee that the two real men were separate interviewees and that the meeting and romance between Pak and Hoi were his invention, and that he supplemented the book with visits to care homes and observation of the living conditions of isolated older people. The strand in which Hoi attends community meetings about an LGBT friendly retirement scheme comes from that fieldwork.

OFFICIAL TRAILER

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What research is this film built on?

Ray Yeung developed it after reading Oral Histories of Older Gay Men in Hong Kong by Travis S. K. Kong, a sociologist at the University of Hong Kong. He contacted Kong, met several interviewees over dinners and home visits, and drew their accounts into a script written between 2016 and 2019.

Did the actors work from that source material too?

Yes. Tai Bo, Ben Yuen and Patra Au built their roles from it, with Au stating that she modelled the wife Ching partly on her cousin's wife. One scene came from an interviewee who hid his Hello Kitty collection before a welfare officer's visit.

What does the advocacy strand add to the story?

A circle of older gay men presses for a retirement home that would house them openly, which places the private romance inside a question about ageing, housing and public recognition rather than leaving it purely personal.

Which awards did the film win?

Two at the 39th Hong Kong Film Awards in 2020: Best Actor for Tai Bo and Best Supporting Actress for Patra Au. It was nominated in five further categories there, and in five at the 56th Golden Horse Awards.

Where did the film premiere and travel?

It world premiered at the 24th Busan International Film Festival on 4 October 2019, went to the Taipei Golden Horse Film Festival, then played Panorama at the 2020 Berlinale, where SBS reported it finished runner up for the Teddy Award.

How did it reach cinemas?

Golden Scene released it in Hong Kong cinemas on 28 May 2020, and Strand Releasing handled the North American release in February 2021 after the film played Frameline and the San Francisco festival.

What makes this film different in Ray Yeung's work?

It is his first shot in his home city and in Cantonese. His earlier features Cut Sleeve Boys and Front Cover were made in Western settings, and he chairs the Hong Kong Lesbian and Gay Film Festival.

What music does the film use?

The Mandarin song Gentle Breeze and Drizzle, performed in the film's version by Qing Shan, written and composed by Lin Gongxin and originally recorded by Liu Lanxi. Original music is credited to Veronica Lee, and no soundtrack album was located.

Who edited the film and how long is it?

It runs 92 minutes, edited by William Chang and Nose Chan, whose work was itself nominated for Best Editing at the 39th Hong Kong Film Awards. New Voice Film Productions produced it in Cantonese.

BLGLFLIX reproduces one poster for this Hong Kong film purely to identify it, with copyright remaining where it always sat; objections are handled under our disclaimer.

Metadata and images courtesy of TMDB. This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB. All posters, portraits, cover art, and promotional materials remain the property of their respective copyright holders and are shown solely to identify the works described. BLGLFLIX does not host or distribute any video content. See our DMCA / Copyright Policy.